The Decision Room

Guide

Why claims without evidence score low with a tender panel

Every submission says the supplier is experienced, committed and flexible. A panel cannot mark any of that. Here is what we look for instead when we score a bid.

The Decision Room

2 min read

When a panel sits down to score written submissions, each evaluator has a scoring sheet, the published criteria and a mark for each one. For every mark, they need a reason they could defend if the buyer asked. That one fact explains most of the marks suppliers lose.

What a panel can and cannot mark

A claim is not evidence. "We have extensive experience of major events" appears in almost every bid. Because everyone says it, it separates no one, and an evaluator cannot point to it as a reason for a higher mark.

Evidence is something the panel can check. A named lead with their role on a comparable project. A project of similar size, with what you delivered and what changed as a result. A figure the buyer could verify. Each of these gives an evaluator something to write in the comments box beside the mark.

Three habits that cost marks

  • Answering your own structure, not the buyer's. If the brief asks five questions in a set order, answer them in that order, under the buyer's headings. An evaluator who has to hunt for an answer may not find it.
  • Saying the team is excellent without naming it. Panels mark the people who will do the work. Name them, give their role on this contract and say what they have done that is relevant.
  • Describing a method without showing it working. A method statement scores when it shows how the approach played out somewhere comparable, not when it lists good intentions.

How to check your own submission

Read each answer and ask what an evaluator would write as the reason for their mark. If the only honest reason is "they say they can", the answer needs evidence. If you can point to a name, a project or a number, it is doing its job.

The written stage decides who is invited to pitch. A submission that gives the panel reasons to mark it up gets you into the room, where the award is settled.

If you want to see how a panel is likely to read your submission before you send it, try the free assessment.

The Decision Room

The Decision Room is built by people who design and run tender processes for sports organisations and sit on the panels that score them.

Keep reading

All posts

Get into the room

See your submission the way the panel will, before it goes in.

Assess a bid free